Critique of the Week

A bracingly honest review from one of LA’s most honest theater critics, love him or hate him, disagree or agree, the one thing Jason always brings is honesty. And that in the end is one of the most essential qualities needed if a theater critic wants to become a trusted entity. Of course you have to know what you’re talking about, and write, but those are topics for another day…

Jason Rohrer – Stage and Cinema


By placing himself in the charge of his fickle children, old King Lear abandons the security of his own reason to wander an inhospitable wilderness. It’s a fitting metaphor for a venerable script at the mercy of a production lacking the chops to do it justice, and for an audience perched for three hours upon some of the least forgiving chairs in any theater in the world.

In my experience, a Porters of Hellsgate show is an earnest conglomeration of youthful optimism and amateur-hour doldrums. A prime factor in this is that a good many of the company members can’t act. The company’s loyalty to these actors is impressive, but it doesn’t do any favors to those of them who can effectively convey character and emotion. That the company places personality above the deserts of a paying public is intolerable in this, a production that may be called professional inasmuch as it charges admission.

A larger problem with the Porters’ new King Lear is that director Thomas Bigley, who very nicely acted the part of Odysseus in last season’s Troilus and Cressida, here seems at a loss for good ideas and good reasons. In updating the story of a feudal king’s self-destruction, Mr. Bigley dresses his players in modern business suits and loads his battle scenes with audible machine-gun fire; one character briefly uses a cell phone. Yet the characters in this anachronistic staging also duel with rapiers and stake their fortunes on Shakespeare’s notoriously unreliable hand-delivered notes rather than instant text-messages, which as any telecommunications user knows could also go astray as the plot dictates. This lack of imagination places the director at a greatest disadvantage in his finest moment: the famous third-act storm, in which Lear wanders raging and bereft, benefits from this production’s single gesture of theatricality, organically-generated raindrop noises swelling under the action. But this welcome piece of ingenuity arrives awkwardly after over an hour of uninterrupted realism; following the storm, no similar device breaks up the extremely prosaic presentation; and even those handmade raindrops are abetted by prerecorded wind and thunder. The show is built of such half-measures. Why, with so few conceptual decisions behind it, this play was chosen to be put up, is another question not answered on the boards of the Studio Stage.

Since most of the actors appear to be in different shows, one may conclude that the directorial advice they received was either not very good or not very much. And although this production features three ringers, actors who could not be bad if you paid them to do it, they are each of them on their own. Larry Cedar, as the ruined king, has a tongue as nimble as his legs. He doesn’t stumble once on some of the choicest syllables in Shakespeare, and he fairly dances his way through the mad scenes; it’s all very committed, if somewhat musical-theater-y. Leon Russom, the reason I go to see any play featuring Leon Russom, plays Gloucester as a weary bureaucrat who more or less deserves his awful fate; it’s a solid and touching performance. But Jo D. Jones, as an exuberant and physical Fool, is robbed of what could have been the defining characterization of this show. The bulk of his scenes have been cut, with the effective result that company members may stand around and mope for the entire, intact falling action. The production, the company, and the audience are all the poorer for it.

Filed Under: colin mitchellcritique of the weekFeaturedPonderingsWeeklies


Colin Mitchell About the Author: COLIN MITCHELL: Actor/Writer/Director/Producer/Father, award-winning playwright and screenwriter, Broadway veteran, Marvel comics scribe, Van Morrison disciple, Zen-Catholic, a proud U.S. Army Brat conceived in Scotland and born in Frankfurt, Germany, currently living in Los Angeles and doing his best to piss off as many people as possible.

RSSComments (2)

Leave a Reply | Trackback URL

  1. Jason Rohrer Jason Rohrer says:

    When are they gonna stop letting that asshole into theaters?